Val's Blog
Lots of stuff for Web 2.0 freaks and Java addicts
Feeds RSS | Atom | RDF
 
 
Albert Einstein: "Intellectuals solve problems: geniuses prevent them."
[ Login ]

May 2004
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
       1 
 2  3  4  5  6  7  8 
 9  10  11  12  13  14  15 
 16  17  18  19  20  21  22 
 23  24  25  26  27  28  29 
 30  31      
Apr  |  Today  |  Jun
XML Feeds   Subscribe with Bloglines

Javaranch Sheriff   My LinkedIn Profile
Drop me a line or two   Bloglines Blogroll
JavaRSS   Referers
How cool are you?   My Reviews

Next trips...
SpringOne 2008 (Jun 11-12, 08)
Ajax Exp. 2008 (Sep 29-Oct 1, 08)
Top 10 entries (#hits)
(As of Nov 30, 2007)


Top 10 entries (#hits/day)
Come Back (5.032)
(As of Nov 30, 2007)
Recent Blog Entries
Recent Blog Comments
Re: Review of "Marketing Management 12th"
i know marketing management by kotler is good book but the problem is that the management part of this book is totally missing as fare as i know managemet is complete different subject and it should not be mixed i am student of MBA i was looking at ass...

Re: Review of "Pro Spring"
Using simple POJOs + factories without Spring for "echo" and "counter" would be a lot more easier. No need to write those XML files... So, in this case using Spring makes me write a lot more code... (OK, you can generate everything with the help of And...

pls urgent
Hi I am trying to generate the word doc but i m not understanding wats happening any one pls figure it out /* * WordAPI.java * * Created on May 30, 2006, 10:50 AM * * To change this template, choose Tools | Template Manager * and open the te...
Archives (# entries)
Links
Other Blogs
Other Blogs

Reviewing
Reading
Locations of visitors to this page
What they once said...
 

I have reviewed "Hardcore Java - Secrets of the Java Masters", the latest title from O'Reilly written by Robert Simmons Jr. I must admit that I'm pretty disappointed with it and I'm not the only one (here, here, here and here).

My opinion is that there were way too many typographical errors in there. Moreover, many topics handled in the book were not that "hardcore" at all. As the book is not that thick (300 pages), I don't think it was wise spending 30 pages on Java 1.5 while a full-blown book from the same publisher (due in June) will be dedicated to the very same subject...

I just hate it when books are rushed to press to the detriment of quality. Coming from a usually high-quality publisher, this really surprised me. Let's hope the second edition will undergo a major rewrite.

My review follows (also available at Javaranch.com):

My first thought when I saw this new book on O’Reilly’s web site was: "Well, there must be some really cool Java hacks hidden behind this rather evocative title."

Basically, it’s one of those books where you expect the next page to actually delve into the real matter and give you some crispy details. My personal impression after finishing it was that the content was a little lightweight for deserving to be qualified as “hardcore”, but maybe I’m being too harsh. The author handles a good deal of “advanced” topics, such as the effective use of Collections and nested classes, constants, immutable types, reflection, proxies and the four different flavors of references. Also qualified as hardcore, the novelties introduced by the upcoming Java 1.5 release are also part of the story...

I have always regarded O’Reilly’s books as high-quality work (and I still do), but I have never been able to find 50 typos in any of their books before. I’m inclined to interpret this fact as if the book had been rushed to press to be on the shelves before JDK 1.5 comes out. I just wish the book had been more thoroughly proofread.

On a more positive note, I’m quite sure medium and advanced Java programmers will be able to distill valuables tips and tricks from this book. On the companion web site, the author also provides the sources of all the examples illustrated in the book.

 
About this Blog